Upcoming Events

Recent Events

Calendar

Regional Groups

Calendar Archive

About SIGS

 

 


 

  SFPFS Tasting SIG Dips Into a Sticky Subject: Marmalade
by Rita Held
www.FoodandWinePros.com


Who would have thought so many marmalades could come from a simple citrus fruit, the orange? SIG participants discovered the breadth and depth of marmalade. We sampled large-batch commercial marmalades as well as artisan products. We tasted marmalades made from Seville oranges (traditional for orange marmalade), blood oranges, mandarins, Rangpur lime, calamondins, and Meyer lemons—even one with a hint of rosemary!

Many of us were most familiar with British or Scottish-style marmalade. This tangy-sweet, sometimes bitter fruit preserve has been around for centuries throughout Europe and the Mediterranean, and was probably first made using quince. The Seville orange is the standard for marmalade in Europe, but Spanish and Sicilian blood oranges, as well as other types of citrus, produce distinct marmalades too—both in color and flavor.

Marmalade ingredients vary. The simplest ones with the fewest ingredients appealed to most tasters—those with just oranges, sugar, and sometimes pectin. Of those least preferred, high fructose corn syrup or glucose syrup often topped the ingredient list. The marmalades were thick and full of chunky rind as one might expect, with a few exceptions noted below.

The following brands won the most votes:

June Taylor Seville Orange Marmalade
– Artisan produced in Berkeley; a tangy marmalade with thinner consistency. $12.00/8 oz. (11 votes)

Insolite & Tradition “Orange Jam”– A French artisan jam available at Market Hall made with French oranges and sugar, this one had a thinner consistency and a hint of honey flavor, though honey was not listed among the ingredients. $9.90/13 oz. (8 votes)

Kitchen Gardens
- A tad bitter, with large chunks of peel, appealing to many marmalade fans. $10.50/12 oz. (6 votes)


June Taylor kindly joined us at the tasting and explained the nuances of marmalade. She brought with her several products, which we all loved: Three-Fruit Marmalade (orange, grapefruit, and lemon), Meyer Lemon infused with rosemary, Page Mandarin, and Blood Orange Marmalade, as well as fruit peels of Rangpur lime and blood orange candied in syrup. June’s preserves are on the tangy side and full of fresh fruit flavor. She hand cuts her fruit and makes her own pectin using the pith and seeds. No commercial pectin is added.

Below are the other brands we tasted. Some of us liked the large-batch marmalades we’ve used for years, not only because of their familiar taste, but because their flavor and consistency works well in recipes. Others were surprised by their elevated sweetness and absence of true fruit flavor after tasting some of the other marmalades.

Brand: Price / Size Tasting Notes

Smuckers: $3.99/18 oz
Classic American-style, lacks flavor compared to others

King Kelly: $3.29/18 oz
California made, classic American-style, very sweet

Chambord: $3.99/11.5 oz
French, very thick and dark, almost gummy

Cross & Blackwell: $3.79/12 oz
British, thick, bitter-sweet

Hero: $3.69/12 oz
Almost like a thick jam, with no discernable chunks of peel

St. Dalfour: $3.69/10 oz very thick, concentrated grape juice gives it a grape flavor, bitter

Charles Chocolates Blood Orange: $11.00/8 oz Thick and chunky, with added orange and lemon that masked the blood orange flavor

Charles Chocolates Meyer Lemon: $11.00/8 oz Soft and cloudy; peel is quite soft

Robert Lambert: $12.99/8 oz Made with exotic citrus fruits including calamondin and Rangpur lime; thick and chunky; some noted a sour taste

Frog Hollow: $6.99/8.4 oz Meyer lemon, tangy, dark color; some complained of a soapy aftertaste

 

 
List of Recent Events

August 2008
Coffee Cupping


June 2008
Honey Tasting SIG


June 2008
Food Writing Book Club SIG


June 2008
Digs Bistro

June 2008
Sauvignon Blanc Showdown

May 2008
A Visit to Careme 350


May 2008
Cooking Teachers SIG


May 2008
San Mateo Members Meet


May 2008
South Bay Members Connect

April 2008
Wine SIG takes a Beaujolais Cruise


April 2008
Demystifying the Food/Wine Dilemma


March 2008
Pasta tasting

March 2008
Cooking Teachers' SIG


March 2008
Traveling Table to Ubuntu

March 2008
Gelato Making

February 2008
Best of Show Cabernet Sauvignons

January 2008
AGM 2008

January 2008
Cooking SIG at Ramekins


January 2008
Stirring the Pot: Future of Chinese Cuisine


December 2007
Marmalade tasting


November 2007
Wine SIG samples sparklers

November 2007
United States of Arugula review


November 2007
Decoding Molecular Gastronomy


October 2007
Career Change Roundtable

October 2007
B Star Bar

September 2007
Barbary BBQ on Maiden Lane


September 2007
Vanilla Tasting


August 2007
Wine SIG tastes Rieslings

June 2007
Wine SIG Rosé Tasting

June 2007
Wines from Livermore

June 2007
Tasting Sig Explores Fetas

June 2007
Dinner at B Restaurant


May 2007
An Evening with Jaques Pepin

April 2007
Knockout Santa Cruz Wines

March 2007
Feasting at Chef Chus


February 2007
Annual General Meeting

February 2007
Lessons from a Master Taster: Darrell Corti


February 2007
East Bay Urban Wine Tour

January 2007
Traveling Table: Radio Africa and Kitchen


December 2006
Holiday Cookie Exchange


November 2006
Southern Foodways Alliance

October 2006
Stirring the Pot with Chuck Williams


October 2006
Wine Sig Looks for Varietal Character


August 2006
SFPFS Barbeque on the USS Hornet


August 2006
Stirring the Pot: Building your Culinary Pedigree

June 2006
Antony Bourdain at the Commonwealth Club


May 2006
Expo West 2006

May 2006
Table Travelers visit Old Mandarin


January 2006
The Annual General Meeting

January 2006
Impressions of Fancy Food, the 31st annual trade show

September 19, 2005
Stirring the Pot: The History, Dynamics, and Ethics of Luxury Dining

June 22, 2005
Stirring the Pot with Nell Newman, Els Cooperrider and Guinness McFadden

May 25, 2005
Brentwood Agricultural Land Trust Fundraising Dinner

May 18. 2005
Philippe Stark and Michel Rolland at the SF W Hotel

April 28, 2005
Roundtable: The Food and Culture of Burma

February 15, 2005
Stirring the Pot with Harold McGee

October 22, 2004
Food Fight! A Lively Discussion of Today's Most Challenging Food Choices

July 12, 2004
Blenheim Apricot Food Tour

May 17, 2004
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Hubert Keller, Michael Mina and Bradley Ogden

March 15, 2004
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Gerald Asher 

February 10, 2004
SFPFS Traveling Table goes to New Delhi Restaurant

January 26, 2004
AGM / NMR Review

November 10, 2003
Reel Food - Castro Theatre

September 25, 2003
Food Tour - Heritage Fruit Orchard at Filoli Gardens

September 17, 2003
Rick Knoll on Organic Farming

June 16, 2003
A Conversation with Thomas Keller: The Soul of Haute Cuisine in America

May 19, 2003
The SFPFS Traveling Table - Roxanne's in Larkspur

April 28, 2003
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Marian Burros and Marion Cunningham

March, 2003
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Marion Nestle

 

         
Home  |  About SFPFS  |   Become a Member  |  Calendar/Events  |  Resources/Links  |  Member Services  |  Newsletter  |  Food in Perspective  |  Contact Us