Upcoming Events

Recent Events

Calendar

Regional Groups

Calendar Archive

About SIGS

 

 


 

 
Stirring the Pot
Decoding Molecular Gastronomy

by Christina Mueller Welter
Photos courtesy Kelly Burgoyne

November 5, 2007

Elizabeth Cawdry Thomas, whose idea brainstorm kick-started the Molecular Gastronomy movement and who set up the first workshop on Molecular and Physical Gastronomy in 1992 in Sicily, was recognized by the SFPFS for her contribution to the field. Elizabeth passed away just days before this event. The event was dedicated to her memory and her significant contribution to today’s food.

The Newest New Nouvelle Cuisine


Speakers Harold McGee, Mark Dommen of One Market, Elizabeth Falkner of Citizen Cake, Citizen Cupcake and the soon-to-be-opened Orson and Daniel Patterson of Coi.

A star-studded panel of chefs and food scientist Harold McGee were on-hand last Monday night at the offices of Ketchum Public Relations to help San Francisco food professionals debunk the myth of molecular gastronomy as whiz-bang, chemically-influenced, as-far-from-the-field-as-it-gets food. Quite the contrary, in fact, as McGee and the chefs Mark Dommen of One Market, Daniel Patterson of Coi and Elizabeth Falkner of Citizen Cake (and soon, Orson) made clear.

Harold McGee signs his book, the revised On Food and Cooking, and chats with admirers.

McGee spoke first and provided a story-arc for the movement. While Spain’s Ferrán Adriá was and continues to be hugely influential and the food press focuses on the “gimmicks” of molecular gastronomy, the reality is that innovation and creativity in professional kitchens is nothing new. The term “molecular gastronomy”, however, is very much new and in vogue. In fact, McGee continued, it is a Chef’s job to innovate, to come up with new ideas and techniques. Adriá “pioneered” the movement in 1988, preceding the physicists meeting in Sicily by four years. Adriá and his English counter-part, Heston Blumenthal, are often referred to as the Fathers of Molecular Gastronomy, but neither is comfortable with the accolade. Blumenthal openly states that he riffs on cooking techniques he found in an 1879 English book on ice cream and McGee mentioned an 1821 cookery book called Culinary Chemistry as a cornerstone or foundation of current cookery. “Cooking is innovation and excellence driven. Science is the tool.”


Daniel Patterson shows off his new book Aroma: the Magic of Essential Oils in Food and Fragrance.

In turn, each of the chefs spoke to their use of these materials in the kitchen then followed-up their words with actions. Xanthan gum, agar, guar gum, lecithin and other materials were deconstructed for the audience’s benefit. Falkner uses xanthan gum, for example, because it does not “sweat” which makes it a better binder than say, gelatin, and produces a finished product with more moisture. This naturally-occurring substance, made from the outer layer of the tiny inactive bacterium called Xanthomonas campestris, is familiar to those who cannot eat gelatin or eggs (vegans), and brings a new audience to Falkner’s restaurants.


Elizabeth Falkner demonstrates the use of agar to make a caramel sauce for her sous-vide chocolate cake.

Agar, derived from seaweed, another binder favored by practitioners of the movement, has been widely used in Asia for centuries as, similarly to xanthan gum, it can better withstand heat and humidity than binders traditionally used in western kitchens. These “new” products and a penchant for innovation enabled Falkner to deconstruct pastry and move the different elements of a dessert to new places on the plate. Falkner presented a dessert where the agar-blended caramel was firm enough to shape into tendrils atop her agar and sous-vide chocolate cake.


Mark Dommon creates a lemon-olive oil emulsion for his sous-vide chicken.

Sous-vide (“under vacuum”), another not-so-new cooking technique (invented in the 1970’s in France), was designed to maintain the integrity of the ingredients by heating them at low temperature over a long time period. It took until the 1990s for this cooking method to achieve wide use in American restaurants.

Every chef spoke to the idea that their craft – cooking - is fundamentally about connecting with customers. The new techniques of the Molecular Gastronomy movement help them to preserve the integrity of the ingredient and create a sense of specialness. It is possible for chefs to play with textures and techniques in a way that was not possible before while maintaining an ingredient’s integrity. The addition of an egg or of cream to a dish to achieve that silky texture is no longer required and the flavor is not dampened. It is lightened and made more delicate.

Falkner's sous-vide chocolate cake with caramel sauce and cocoa-nib explosion with samples.

Foam, the essence of lightness and the eternal punching bag for customers who disparage the movement, is often nothing more than an emulsion. As Dommen said: “People just think that emulsions are foams.” Patterson further clarified: “Foam is a touchstone, it represents to many people that we have lost touch with our cultural traditions. But the reality is that sabayon (a light, frothy dessert made with egg yolks, wine and sometimes cream) [sic] is a foam.” Texture and taste will continue to drive what chefs put on their menus.

Perceived by many as labor-intensive and fussy, every chef mentioned that the addition of these techniques in their kitchen does not increase their staffing needs one iota. The foundation techniques of cookery are still the most important tools in a chef’s toolkit. Molecular Gastronomy adds a new dimension to that toolkit but does not replace it.


Triple chocolate dessert from Gold sponsor Guittard.

In sum, Molecular Gastronomy is not so new. It does have a new name and it allows chefs to create new textures and whisper-light flavors previously not seen – a boon to individuality and creativity. It is all about the cooking. It always has been.

May the Bay Area find room in its generous heart for this creative and fun movement!

Linda Carucci, Nancy Kux and Gary Arsham taste cheeses donated by Bronze sponsor Cheeseworks West.


Fudge brownies with Cherries and white chocolate from Ketchum Chef Catherine Pantsios.



Elizabeth Falkner signs her new book  "Demolition Desserts: Recipes from Citizen Cake."


Guest Deirdre O'Shea, San Francisco Magazine Food Editor Jan Newberry, Gold sponsor Kelly Burgoyne and Food Society President Nancy Freeman pose for a photo op.


Mini roast beef sandwiches provided by Gold sponsor Ketchum's Pantsios.



A royal spread of cheeses provided by Cheeseworks West.




 
 
List of Recent Events

August 2008
Coffee Cupping


June 2008
Honey Tasting SIG


June 2008
Food Writing Book Club SIG


June 2008
Digs Bistro

June 2008
Sauvignon Blanc Showdown

May 2008
A Visit to Careme 350


May 2008
Cooking Teachers SIG


May 2008
San Mateo Members Meet


May 2008
South Bay Members Connect

April 2008
Wine SIG takes a Beaujolais Cruise


April 2008
Demystifying the Food/Wine Dilemma


March 2008
Pasta tasting

March 2008
Cooking Teachers' SIG


March 2008
Traveling Table to Ubuntu

March 2008
Gelato Making

February 2008
Best of Show Cabernet Sauvignons

January 2008
AGM 2008

January 2008
Cooking SIG at Ramekins


January 2008
Stirring the Pot: Future of Chinese Cuisine


December 2007
Marmalade tasting


November 2007
Wine SIG samples sparklers

November 2007
United States of Arugula review


November 2007
Decoding Molecular Gastronomy


October 2007
Career Change Roundtable

October 2007
B Star Bar

September 2007
Barbary BBQ on Maiden Lane


September 2007
Vanilla Tasting


August 2007
Wine SIG tastes Rieslings

June 2007
Wine SIG Rosé Tasting

June 2007
Wines from Livermore

June 2007
Tasting Sig Explores Fetas

June 2007
Dinner at B Restaurant


May 2007
An Evening with Jaques Pepin

April 2007
Knockout Santa Cruz Wines

March 2007
Feasting at Chef Chus


February 2007
Annual General Meeting

February 2007
Lessons from a Master Taster: Darrell Corti


February 2007
East Bay Urban Wine Tour

January 2007
Traveling Table: Radio Africa and Kitchen


December 2006
Holiday Cookie Exchange


November 2006
Southern Foodways Alliance

October 2006
Stirring the Pot with Chuck Williams


October 2006
Wine Sig Looks for Varietal Character


August 2006
SFPFS Barbeque on the USS Hornet


August 2006
Stirring the Pot: Building your Culinary Pedigree

June 2006
Antony Bourdain at the Commonwealth Club


May 2006
Expo West 2006

May 2006
Table Travelers visit Old Mandarin


January 2006
The Annual General Meeting

January 2006
Impressions of Fancy Food, the 31st annual trade show

September 19, 2005
Stirring the Pot: The History, Dynamics, and Ethics of Luxury Dining

June 22, 2005
Stirring the Pot with Nell Newman, Els Cooperrider and Guinness McFadden

May 25, 2005
Brentwood Agricultural Land Trust Fundraising Dinner

May 18. 2005
Philippe Stark and Michel Rolland at the SF W Hotel

April 28, 2005
Roundtable: The Food and Culture of Burma

February 15, 2005
Stirring the Pot with Harold McGee

October 22, 2004
Food Fight! A Lively Discussion of Today's Most Challenging Food Choices

July 12, 2004
Blenheim Apricot Food Tour

May 17, 2004
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Hubert Keller, Michael Mina and Bradley Ogden

March 15, 2004
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Gerald Asher 

February 10, 2004
SFPFS Traveling Table goes to New Delhi Restaurant

January 26, 2004
AGM / NMR Review

November 10, 2003
Reel Food - Castro Theatre

September 25, 2003
Food Tour - Heritage Fruit Orchard at Filoli Gardens

September 17, 2003
Rick Knoll on Organic Farming

June 16, 2003
A Conversation with Thomas Keller: The Soul of Haute Cuisine in America

May 19, 2003
The SFPFS Traveling Table - Roxanne's in Larkspur

April 28, 2003
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Marian Burros and Marion Cunningham

March, 2003
Stirring the Pot: A Conversation with Marion Nestle

 

         
Home  |  About SFPFS  |   Become a Member  |  Calendar/Events  |  Resources/Links  |  Member Services  |  Newsletter  |  Food in Perspective  |  Contact Us